4 repos · 22 commands · 5 broken · 2 slow · 4 filed
Newcomer session on scott-mbp (macOS arm64) against main 41d768c81 built from source. I re-checked the 6 fixed issues (2568, 2569, 2570 fixed; 2574 and 2390 still reproduce; 2563 is Windows-only). I then went deeper on APFS collision handling, conflict flows (pull --rebase, pick, merge, stash pop), unreadable/read-only paths, 8-way concurrent serve checkout/checkin/integrate and a first library program. Beginner-facing errors and hints are very good and the conflict flows match git, but the APFS case/normalization collision paths still have real data-integrity bugs (#2575, #2576) and stash show leaks raw control bytes (#2580).
| repo | files | commits | .git | notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| octocat/Hello-World | 1 | 3 | 1 MB | |
| git/git | 4,866 | 82,797 | 324 MB | |
| gitbutlerapp/grit | 3,479 | 13,544 | 199 MB | also served via grit serve and cloned/checked out through it |
| scratch collision/conflict/permission repos | 5 | 3 | 1 MB | crash1, crash2, case-*, cf, sp, ro, ur, fn, uni, ex, pr, pd |
| command | repo | grit | git | grit/git | result | notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| grit status | git/git | 13 ms | 13 ms | 1.0× | ok | hyperfine, 5 runs |
| grit log --oneline -n 1000 | git/git | 8.8 ms | 10 ms | 0.9× | ok | |
| grit diff HEAD~100 HEAD | git/git | 19 ms | 38 ms | 0.5× | ok | |
| grit revs --count HEAD | git/git | 305 ms | 371 ms | 0.8× | ok | |
| grit blame builtin/log.c | git/git | 365 ms | 343 ms | 1.1× | ok | no differing lines vs git |
| grit blame builtin/commit.c (compare to git) | git/git | — | — | — | wrong | 4/1993 lines credited to merge commits (#2574 not fully fixed) |
| grit switch --detach <20000 commits back> | git/git | 450 ms | 550 ms | 0.8× | ok | |
| grit switch --detach master (back) | git/git | 400 ms | 550 ms | 0.7× | ok | |
| grit clone <local path> | git/git | 390 ms | 1.04 s | 0.4× | ok | .git 324 MB both |
| grit clone http://127.0.0.1 (grit serve) | gitbutlerapp/grit | 3.68 s | 7.63 s | 0.5× | ok | git client clone of grit serve: 7.2-7.6 s, fsck clean |
| grit upload-pack --stateless-rpc (4M duplicate wants) | octocat/Hello-World | 600 ms | — | — | memory | #2390 still reproduces |
| grit upload-pack --stateless-rpc (19M duplicate wants) | octocat/Hello-World | — | — | — | memory | request buffered fully; #2390 |
| grit restore . / restore Readme.TXT (case-colliding) | scratch collision/conflict/permission repos | — | — | — | crash | #2575 |
| grit commit (NFC/NFD colliding tracked names) | scratch collision/conflict/permission repos | — | — | — | wrong | #2576 |
| grit stash show (names with ESC/tab/newline) | scratch collision/conflict/permission repos | — | — | — | wrong | #2580 |
| grit status/add/commit on case-colliding clone | scratch collision/conflict/permission repos | — | — | — | wrong | contradictory hints, #2581 |
| grit diff HEAD~800 HEAD --stat in blobless clone via grit serve | gitbutlerapp/grit | 1.26 s | 1.31 s | 1.0× | ok | grit leaves 21 packs vs git 3 (lazy fetch batching, see #2327); time equal so not filed |
| grit pull --rebase (2 conflicting stops) / rebase --continue / commit mid-rebase | scratch collision/conflict/permission repos | — | — | — | ok | |
| grit rebase main --exec | scratch collision/conflict/permission repos | — | — | — | ok | failing exec leaves everything untouched; message does not say which commit failed (minor) |
| grit pick / merge / stash pop with dir-file and modify-delete conflicts | scratch collision/conflict/permission repos | — | — | — | ok | matches git's index state except stash pop d dir->file (no file/directory conflict reported; nothing lost) |
| grit checkout/checkin/integrate x8 concurrently | gitbutlerapp/grit | 2.19 s | — | — | ok | checkout 8 in 2.2 s; 2 of 8 integrates correctly rejected with HTTP 409 |
| grit clone --blobs none (serve with allowFilter) | gitbutlerapp/grit | 3.96 s | — | — | ok | 29 MB .git vs 186 MB when the server lacks allowFilter (documented, warns) |